2:00PM Water Cooler 6/28/2024: Biden v. Trump Publish-Match Evaluation and Commentary

By Lambert Strether of Corrente

Readers, at present’s Water Cooler is a submit, however I included the chicken tune and the plant, as a result of I knew you’d ding me if I didn’t! –lambert

Chook Track of the Day

Jap Meadowlark, Brazoria NWR–Auto Tour Loop and Discovery Middle, Brazoria, Texas, United States.
.

The chaos within the Democrats get together is maybe finest understood as a succession disaster, not merely personally, however generationally (Biden’s substitute, if any, is unlikely to be 81, and even much less prone to be a member of the Senate class of 1973).

Furthermore, it’s a disaster that must be solved by deadline: The bodily Chicago conference is August 19-22, however the Democrat Nationwide Committee (DNC) has determined to carry a digital nomination on Zoom, as a result of Republican Ohio required an August 7 submitting date to get the Democrat nominee on their poll. (Ohio has since moved the submitting date to September 1, however Democrats don’t belief them.) The date of the Zoom nomination is, nevertheless, as but unrevealed. Let’s say the date is August 6. That is June 28, making the deadline 39 days away. If the date seems to be August 19 in any case, the disaster have to be resolved in 52 days. That’s not loads of time.

Whether or not the Democrat succession disaster is of historic significance is as but unknown (requested the identical query of the French Revolution, Chou En-Lai is claimed to have stated “It’s too early to say”). Actually it’s vital within the historical past of the get together, although it’s exhausting to think about a precedent: When Democrats cut up in 1860, it was over an vital precept — slavery — and never over the get together’s growing older star and weak bench. Actually the talk is critical, although whether or not on the order of Bush v. Gore 2000 (which Gore was thought to have received for a information cycle or so, till the press determined the talk was actually about Gore sighing obnoxiously) or Kennedy v. Nixon 1960 (a poor analogy with no Camelot within the offing) can be unknown.

I spent a number of hours after the talk trawling the Twitter, and some hours after that studying up on the bigfootery and hot-take-ish-ness, and in what follows I’m going to empty out my haul into the next buckets, which correspond roughly to opinion-havers within the Democrat Occasion construction (ignoring the spooks, press property, and NGOs):

1) Tragedians

2) The Wizard of Kalorama™

3) Occasion Grandees

4) Bedwetters

5) Non-Bedwetters

6) Occasion Members and Activists

7) Outsiders

8) Fanciful Scenarists

My object is to not predict the longer term — although I do recall asserting that “volatility” was to be this 12 months’s theme — however to attempt to cut back the mass of fabric to some form of order. (Readers will observe that there’s one additional class I’ve neglected: Funders. That’s as a result of squillionaires and even native gentry are few in quantity, have ideological crotchets, have to be serviced, and canopy their tracks, which is why Ferguson and his associates must take time to determine — in granular and never class phrases — who the string-pullers actually are (I say “string-pullers” fairly than “puppet masters” as a result of the members of each bucket have their very own relative autonomy)).

I’m going to construction the buckets fairly just like the membership sandwich I had for lunch: The bacon, lettuce, and so forth would be the Tweets I collected; the slices of bread will likely be hyperlinks to the opinion-havers. As a result of that is Water Cooler, the sandwich will likely be massive at first, and assume Dagwoodian proportions as soon as orts and scraps are added.

However earlier than I begin filling up buckets, let me have some enjoyable and do a Wordle for every canidate. I’m utilizing the CNN transcript.

Biden:

Trump:

Make of them what you’ll. (These are easy frequency-based Wordles. I’m frankly stunned “horrible” doesn’t assume better salience in Trump’s Wordle; the way in which he pronounced it actually sticks within the thoughts. Discover, nevertheless, that “nation” is central to Trump’s attraction, however not Biden’s.)

Tragedians

However nonetheless evoking pity and terror:

Time to take the automobile keys away (1):

Trump, amazingly, stays managed, offers a slight shrug, then does what he has to do.

Time to take the automobile keys away (2):

Time to take the automobile keys away (3):

Time to take the automobile keys away (4):

The Democrats have kind on elder abuse:

Rigorously uncommitted:

The after-party, poor Jill (1):

Poor Jill (2):

The Wizard of Kalorama™

UPDATE The Wizard™ speaks:

The framing is misleading. The difficulty isn’t one unhealthy debate. The difficulty is a failing debater.

Obama’s speechwriter (coined “The Blob”) takes a view:

From Obama’s marketing campaign supervisor:

However from Obama’s former chief strategist–

“Axelrod: Biden Is The Nominee Of The Democratic Occasion, “This Isn’t The 60s” [RealClearPolitics]. “[AXELROD:] The purpose is now he’s the nominee of the Democratic Occasion. This isn’t the 60s, okay. Voters select the nominee. He’s the nominee solely he can resolve whether or not he’s going to proceed, and as you level out, this can be a man with loads of delight who believes in himself. The concept he’s going to say, ‘You realize, I had a nasty debate, I feel I’m going to stroll away from this.’ I discover it exhausting to imagine.”

“A halting Biden tries to confront Trump at debate however sparks Democratic anxiousness about his candidacy” [Associated Press]. “‘I feel the panic had set in,’ stated David Axelrod, a longtime advisor to former President Barack Obama on CNN, instantly after the talk about Biden’s efficiency. ‘And I feel you’re going to listen to discussions that, I don’t know will result in something, however there are going to be discussions about whether or not he ought to proceed.’”

Occasion Grandees

“A Fumbling Efficiency, and a Panicking Occasion” [Peter Baker, New York Times]. “Democrats on Thursday night time have been imagining situations that might require get together elders like Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, former Speaker Nancy Pelosi of California and Consultant James E. Clyburn of South Carolina to intervene with the president, though there was no indication that any of them would agree to take action.” • See this calmly sourced story from the Every day Mail on June 17, which presents the same state of affairs: “‘The one individuals who might drive him out can be Barack Obama, Invoice Clinton, Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer,’ one Democratic strategist instructed DailyMail.com. ‘It must be the 4 of them collectively.’” Baker, apparently, substituted Clyburn for Obama.

“Playbook: Democrats get up to a nightmare” [Politico]. “The important thing names we saved listening to final night time have been listed in three concentric rings of affect across the president, beginning with (1) his household, notably spouse JILL and sister VALERIE BIDEN, (2) his closest advisers (TED KAUFMAN, TOM DONILON, RON KLAIN, STEVE RICCHETTI and ANITA DUNN), after which (3) the bold-faced electeds and former electeds whose opinions he couldn’t ignore (Invoice and HILLARY CLINTON, Obama, Pelosi, Schumer, Clyburn, Delaware Sen. CHRIS COONS).” • Concerning ring (1), and why on earth haven’t Jill and Hunter taken Joe apart and stated “Honey, let’s spend our final months collectively”? That household is just not the best it’s made out to be (because the canines as vicious as their grasp present).

“In The Room The place It Occurs” [Atrios, Eschaton]. “Most of us don’t get to be there, however there are at all times individuals with entry to lawmakers and the administration who’re continuously placing strain on them. The individuals making an attempt to make noise on the skin – livid weblog posts, indignant tweets, public protest – are those who don’t ever get that entry. A few of that strain comes from huge donors, some from their weirdo wealthy pals within the group chat, some from the quite a few lobbying teams who’ve armies of people who find themselves paid to lie for his or her trigger (and who even have all of your favourite journalists of their contact lists). And, in fact, those that dangle lifetime family and friends jobs. It’s the ‘quiet’ strain individuals must be extra nervous about. It’s fixed and relentless and far more efficient than something outsiders can do.” • So….

Bedwetters

That escalated shortly:

“Very aggressive panic”:

“A number of lists” (flex nets):

“Zero constituency”?

Wasserman is a sober and impartial observer:

“McCaskill says Biden stumbles increase query of Harris or Newsom at prime of Democratic ticket” [The Hill]. McCaskill: “‘[Harris and Newsom] are signaling to an entire lot of Individuals who’re paying consideration, ‘How come they don’t seem to be on the prime of the ticket?” McCaskill stated in an interview with Rachel Maddow on MSNBC after the talk. ‘How come the Democratic get together doesn’t have them on the prime of the ticket, as an alternative of utilizing them to shore up some fairly obvious weaknesses in our president?’” • First Democrat common I’ve seen to overtly throw Harris beneath the bus (by proposing Newsom instead).

Non-Bedwetters

“Biden speaks at Georgia Waffle Home following debate efficiency: ‘I feel we did properly’” [FOX]. “‘I feel we did properly,’ Biden instructed reporters at an Atlanta space Waffle Home when requested how he carried out. When requested if he had any considerations about his efficiency, the president stated, ‘No it’s exhausting to debate a liar, New York Occasions pointed how he lied 26 occasions. Large lies.’ Biden was then requested if he was affected by a chilly, which the marketing campaign revealed following the talk efficiency the place many expressed considerations concerning the sound of Biden’s voice. ‘I’m sick,’ Biden stated.” • However not with a chilly?

Saying what she has to say:

Newsom promoting exhausting (1):

Newsom promoting exhausting (2):

Hillary Clinton’s press secretary coping:

(She could possibly be proper, in fact.)

Former Biden Press Secretary coping:

Fetterman has a degree, type of:

Fetterman had a nasty debate post-stroke and nonetheless received. However stroke was one thing Fetterman might get better from, and did. No matter is occurring to Biden doesn’t seem like a reversible course of.

Admirably dedicated to the bit, however nonetheless cope:

Elias is the Democrat go-to on election legislation, and a conduit for Steele File cash (and to be honest, an skilled on election legislation is required; maybe not the fatally compromised Elias, although.)

Extra cope, decoped:

“Is There a Good Motive To not Panic? Nicely, No, Not Actually” [The New Republic]. “The ultimate possibility, subsequently, is to throw the factor open and attempt to get the nomination to one of many governors, or another person. This has at all times had loads of theoretical attraction, as a result of a number of of those individuals seem like they’d be good candidates However the two perceived issues with this state of affairs are these. First, how a lot unhealthy blood would begin boiling inside the get together if Harris have been pushed apart? The assumed reply has at all times been: rather a lot. If Biden have been to step apart, pollsters would begin asking questions on Harris, and if these polls confirmed that Black girls will principally bolt, going round Harris could possibly be a nonstarter. And second, is there actually any proof that Gretchen Whitmer or Gavin Newsom or Josh Shapiro or Jay Pritzker or anybody else can be a greater candidate? Governors typically simply don’t have it on the subject of operating for president. Have a look at Ron DeSantis. These are actual issues. However on this break-glass second, they begin to seem like smaller issues than staying with Biden or simply handing it to Harris. We’ll see what the post-debate polls say. They’ll begin popping out early to mid-next week. My guess is that Biden will lose 4 factors on common, possibly 5. It is likely to be rather less. However the protection of this fiasco over the following two days will solely amplify how unhealthy it was.”l

“Joe Biden’s debate gamble backfires” [Mark Penn, FOX]. “About one of the best factor the marketing campaign can hope for is {that a} well-staged conference can undo this harm and that they will get their candidate one other look. There will likely be chatter a couple of new nominee however, as David Axelrod noticed, the delegates have been chosen and the votes forged in a democratic course of and the one one that can change that’s Joe Biden himself. The get together will proceed to shut ranks behind Biden. ”

Occasion Members and Activists

Refusual to manage:

Changing the votes of those that voted for Biden, too:

“Our democracy”….

Outsiders

Thanks, Obama!

Silicon Valley, however not a tech bro, rip-off artist, or libertarian (sorry for the redundancy):

Fanciful Scenarists

I imagine Biden might additionally launch his delegates:

Of the Trillbillies:

Reminiscence gap? What reminiscence gap?

Twenty Fifth Modification:

Too many transferring elements in Twenty Fifth Modification, I feel.

A faithless elector:

To Tim Mellon, $10M is a gratuity!

“It was a set-up” (1):

As I’ve stated earlier than, I feel all events thought an early debate would convey readability.

“It was a set-up (2):

And about Biden’s hoarseness:

What no person’s saying:

Conclusion

If the Democrats are to switch Biden, they’ve 52 days on the exterior to decide on his successor, introduce them to the general public, and switch the tanker of the marketing campaign (moreover changing all of Biden’s employees). That’s a heavy elevate.

So who may Biden’s successor be? We’ve two nearly ineffective knowledge factors as of this writing. First, prediction markets:

Fairly the value swing. Second, this ballot at Drudge:

Who the heck is “Different”? Oprah? Arnold? Michelle? Taylor Swift?

Then in fact there are bigger crises that the Biden Administration has on its plate:

(Observe that one might regard the Israel Foyer as a proxy for the military-industrial advanced whereas nonetheless accepting Mearsheimer’s backside line.) Busy, busy, busy!

APPENDIX

The main focus teams start to talk:

“Undecided voter focus group leans towards Trump after debate” [Axios]. “All undecided voters in a U.S. swing states focus group hosted by pollster Frank Luntz stated President Biden must be changed because the Democratic nominee after watching his first presidential debate towards former President Trump. Why it issues: The 2024 presidential election will likely be determined by roughly 6% of voters in key swing states. Luntz, who has performed presidential focus teams since 1996, stated he by no means witnessed one attain a ‘conclusion this overwhelming.’ Of 14 voters from Pennsylvania, Georgia, Arizona, Michigan, Nevada and North Carolina, 12 stated the talk made them lean towards electing Trump, one towards Biden and one remained undecided. 9 of the individuals stated they voted for Biden in 2020. Most voters expressed concern over Biden’s psychological state and his capability to guide, following some rambling solutions from the president.”

Contact info for crops: Readers, be at liberty to contact me at lambert [UNDERSCORE] strether [DOT] corrente [AT] yahoo [DOT] com, to (a) learn the way to ship me a test if you’re allergic to PayPal and (b) to learn the way to ship me photographs of crops. Greens are advantageous! Fungi, lichen, and coral are deemed to be honorary crops! If you need your deal with to look as a credit score, please place it at the beginning of your mail in parentheses: (thus). In any other case, I’ll anonymize through the use of your initials. See the earlier Water Cooler (with plant) right here. From EM:

EM write: “How we doing? I can’t wait to inject this into my arm.” You and me each.

Readers: Water Cooler is a standalone entity not coated by the annual NC fundraiser. So if you happen to see a hyperlink you particularly like, or an merchandise you wouldn’t see wherever else, please don’t hesitate to specific your appreciation in tangible kind. Keep in mind, a tip jar is for tipping! Common optimistic suggestions each makes me really feel good and lets me know I’m heading in the right direction with protection. After I get no donations for 3 or 4 days I get nervous. Extra tangibly, a continuing trickle of donations helps me with bills, and I consider that trickle when setting fundraising targets:

Right here is the display screen that may seem, which I’ve helpfully annotated:

In the event you hate PayPal, you’ll be able to e-mail me at lambert [UNDERSCORE] strether [DOT] corrente [AT] yahoo [DOT] com, and I will provide you with instructions on ship a test. Thanks!