Following up on Jim’s publish yesterday, ideas on measurement error and prospects. Word that GDP stunned on the draw back, at 1.6 ppts q/q AR vs. consensus 2.5 ppts. However, GDP+ grows quicker, as does closing gross sales to personal home purchasers.
Determine 1: GDP (daring black), GDPNow as of 4/24 (mild blue sq.), GDPNow as of 4/26 (blue sq.), NY Fed nowcast as of 4/26 (crimson inverted triangle), April WSJ survey imply (mild inexperienced), CBO estimate of potential GDP (grey), all in bn.Ch.2017$ SAAR. Supply: BEA (2024Q1 advance), Atlanta Fed, NY Fed, CBO Funds and Financial Outlook (February 2024), and creator’s calculations.
Whereas 1.6 ppts appears far under 2.5 ppts (q/q AR), recall that this advance estimate shall be revised, maybe considerably. As famous on this BEA word from October 2023 (for pattern interval 1996-2022):
Supply: BEA (2023).
What about various measures of financial exercise. Under I plot reported (expenditure aspect) GDP, GDO (the common of GDI and GDP), and GDP+, and in a separate graph, closing gross sales to personal home purchasers, which is usually interpreted as a greater measure of combination demand.
Determine 2: Prime panel: GDP (daring black), GDO (tan), GDP+ listed to stage of 2019Q4 GDP (mild blue). Backside panel: Closing gross sales to personal home purchasers (daring black). All in bn.Ch.2017$ SAAR. GDI is estimated based mostly on 2.2% y/y development on internet working surplus part. Supply: BEA 2024Q1 advance launch, Philadelphia Fed, and creator’s calculations.
On a q/q AR foundation, estimated GDO isn’t rising in any respect. The lacking part of GDI I crammed in with a 2.2% development in internet working surplus, utilizing a 2.2% forecasted development in company earnings for Q1. Which means that actual internet working surplus is assumed to renew its decline in Q1.
Determine 3: Web working surplus in bn.$ SAAR (blue, left scale), and in bn.Ch.2017$, SAAR (tan, proper scale). Deflated utilizing GDP deflator. Supply: BEA and creator’s calculations.
Whereas each GDO and GDP+ have decelerated (the previous to 0 ppts), closing gross sales continues apace (3% q/q AR), suggesting continued momentum in combination demand.
